Jump to content



Motor Vehicle Insurance: Losing Sight of the Social Dimension?

By Blogger on 22 May 2011

Attached Image: images.jpg

Money not enough! You might be used to hearing this complaint from your fellow man on the street, but in recent years, even the bigwigs at the major insurers on our shores seem to be singing the same tune.

As insurance premiums are hiked repeatedly, the insurance industry frequently trots out figures to show that it has been chalking up losses to justify the price hikes. The underlying assumption is simple; insurers are businesses accountable to shareholders and are under no obligation to subsidize the driving costs of Singaporeans. Fair enough?

Perhaps not so.

It must remembered that unlike most other insurance products, motor vehicle insurance is mandatory. It is mandatory as a matter of social policy. The powers that be do not want a situation where drivers cause damage to lives and property but are unable to compensate the victims for the losses incurred. It is fine and dandy to take your own risks, but not for innocent victims to do so. That is why third party insurance is acceptable.

And herein lies the great difference, motor vehicle insurance is a matter of providing a social benefit. When we look at all other forms of mandatory insurance in Singapore, we can see that insurers charge a low and competitive premium. So why not for motor vehicle insurance?

Now, the next line of argument that the insurers might bring up would be that the social policy is a matter determined by the state and they, as private entities, can voluntarily decide when they wish to toe the government's line. Fair enough?

Once again; perhaps not so.

Ultimately, corporations owe their birth and right to do business to the state. The state grants these corporations limited liability; it grants these insurance companies the right to be involved in insurance. What the state gives, it can take away. It is not an entitlement that they are allowed to run their billion dollar empires.

With this in mind, it is of course unrealistic to expect an industry used to cushy profits to suddenly become social minded. The best way to deal with this problem is for the government to step in. And I don't mean pushing the insurers to keep insurance affordable.

I mean a true overhaul of the system - make motor vehicle insurance voluntary and set up a simple claims framework for victims to put up a quick claim (like the small claims tribunal). No lawyers, no insurers. If you are insured, your insurer will simply pay on your behalf after the determination of liability is made. If you are not insured, the victim has the full gamut of court enforcement against you and your property. If that is insufficient, the remainder will come from the assurance fund. This assurance fund will be funded by part of COE takings. In return, COE will be adjusted so there is a minimum bid of $X where $X represents the flat fee that every new car buyer should put into the assurance fund. No more feeding the insurers unless you want to. No more bearing the increase from reckless drivers and inflated claims unless you want to.

discussions, local, insurance and 3 more...

Viewed: 738 times

Related Blog Posts
Written by Blogger
Not only do their passion for cars burn pavements, their thoughts and ideas on cars are as fast as the word go.

  • 1
Friendstar May 22 2011 12:35 PM
No lawyers? U must be dreaming.
Kangadrool May 22 2011 10:40 PM
not business-friendly leh. Confirm won't be supported by Garment one!
SGCMwind79 May 22 2011 11:10 PM
Inform the new transport minister...
Notsogoodman May 23 2011 02:38 AM
If motor insurance is voluntary, that will be the start of accidents & claims headaches...
Darthrevan May 23 2011 11:33 PM
if motor insurance is voluntary, i bet most pple won't even bother to buy..and any one will just chiong to buy a car..crash, forget and run..i'm definitely against that
Suv8 May 23 2011 11:34 PM
motoring is a luxury, not a necessity, unlike medical insurance. So it may be better for those who cannot afford, not to drive.
  • 1
Car Makes

Please select a car make

Facebook Likes
   Featured Blog Post
Volkswagen has revealed that its ‘R’ brand performance models will soon become more wild and less...
An American publication has found some documents pointing out that the Mazda MX-5 could get a dec...
The Hyundai i30 N has been well-received by hot hatch fans but for those who prefer to not shift...
When we interviewed the Assistant Large Project Leader of the 2017 Honda Civic Type R, he said th...
This year’s Geneva Motor Show saw the launch of the McLaren Senna GTR and although it is only a c...
Toyota has officially confirmed that the upcoming Supra that's been co-developed with BMW wil...
   Lifestyle Articles