Scb11980 1st Gear October 17, 2011 Share October 17, 2011 Why tax items bought abroad for personal use? Letter from Charlton Wee 17 Oct 2011 Today I recently returned to Singapore from a trip to Hong Kong and was stopped to have my baggage checked for any undeclared goods. My luggage was packed with herbs for my family, and I was questioned about contents that I did not know the worth of, as they were given to me by my relative in Hong Kong. I had to give an estimate based on my experience of purchasing herbs in Singapore, as I was told I could be taxed. I found out that all Singaporeans are allowed only up to S$300 worth of non-taxable goods, a rule that no one knew when I asked around later. I can understand it if we are taxed on goods for commercial use or business purposes, but why are we taxed on goods bought overseas that are solely for personal consumption? ↡ Advertisement Link to post Share on other sites More sharing options...
Falcon1668 Neutral Newbie October 17, 2011 Share October 17, 2011 can, who say cannot? depends on who you are ..... remember the 16% discount on condo purchase? the buyers also act blur, but no action taken Link to post Share on other sites More sharing options...
Caaa Clutched October 17, 2011 Share October 17, 2011 Why tax items bought abroad for personal use? Letter from Charlton Wee 17 Oct 2011 Today I recently returned to Singapore from a trip to Hong Kong and was stopped to have my baggage checked for any undeclared goods. My luggage was packed with herbs for my family, and I was questioned about contents that I did not know the worth of, as they were given to me by my relative in Hong Kong. I had to give an estimate based on my experience of purchasing herbs in Singapore, as I was told I could be taxed. I found out that all Singaporeans are allowed only up to S$300 worth of non-taxable goods, a rule that no one knew when I asked around later. I can understand it if we are taxed on goods for commercial use or business purposes, but why are we taxed on goods bought overseas that are solely for personal consumption? It pretty difficult to differentiate "personal use" or "for re-sales"....either side would have reasons to prove otherwise but its always come with benefit of doubt. To prevent these, a clear cut amount is stated so as to use as bench mark.... However, those guy are quite fair actually, if you bought an expensive handbag (just one piece) which easily cost more than $300, they would still "give chance" though technically they could have tax u. Its good to know the rules, regulation & law....its better to know if they use discretion and give chance.....so that one would not argue "wrongly". Cheers! Link to post Share on other sites More sharing options...
Neost 6th Gear October 17, 2011 Share October 17, 2011 Why tax items bought abroad for personal use? Letter from Charlton Wee 17 Oct 2011 Today I found out that all Singaporeans are allowed only up to S$300 worth of non-taxable goods, a rule that no one knew when I asked around later. This rule is always there. I remember I do see pasted notice in the arrival hall mentioning something like that too. Although there is such rule, the authority usually close one eye as long as the qty bought in is reasonable. I don't think is their intention to create a scene or make the experience of fellow citizen who just return from a nice holiday abroad bad. How much can they charge the returning traveller on the GST? They might as well concentrate their effort to catch those contraband cigaratte sellers. It will show up better in their annual work review. Imagine under the achievement section you put down "I caught and fine 10 senior citizens for bring in tea leaves without declaring for GST". If I am their reporting officer, I will [bigcry] For the custom officer to stop and ask you for the value of the purchase, I can imagine the "qty" we are talking about. The writer Charlton Wee must be thinking we will all sympathise with him. Sorry lor, although we complain and complain, we are also sensible. Link to post Share on other sites More sharing options...
Dafansu Turbocharged October 17, 2011 Share October 17, 2011 the tax already been there for many years http://www.customs.gov.sg/leftNav/trav/Dut...+GST+Relief.htm Link to post Share on other sites More sharing options...
D3badge 6th Gear October 17, 2011 Share October 17, 2011 (edited) delete Edited October 17, 2011 by D3badge Link to post Share on other sites More sharing options...
Tjkbeluga 5th Gear October 17, 2011 Share October 17, 2011 Another case of, "If want to fine why fine only me" Link to post Share on other sites More sharing options...
Shull Turbocharged October 17, 2011 Share October 17, 2011 Btw, this is NOT a fine.. just asking him to pay the GST nia.. Link to post Share on other sites More sharing options...
Tayspiderx 3rd Gear October 17, 2011 Share October 17, 2011 May be yr herbs looks like very x ginseng? cordyceps? But $300??? worth of tax?? $21?? Shouldnt ICA be more concern on illicit weapons and drugs... Link to post Share on other sites More sharing options...
13177 Supersonic October 17, 2011 Share October 17, 2011 (edited) Heard even if you buy too many clothing or shoes back from your holidays, the sg custom can also "tax" the items you have bought?! Edited October 17, 2011 by 13177 Link to post Share on other sites More sharing options...
Babyt 4th Gear October 17, 2011 Share October 17, 2011 maybe its 1 full big luggages of expensive herbs to be sold in his shop? Charlton must tell us what herb is it... Link to post Share on other sites More sharing options...
Scb11980 1st Gear October 17, 2011 Author Share October 17, 2011 can, who say cannot? depends on who you are ..... remember the 16% discount on condo purchase? the buyers also act blur, but no action taken What talking you????? Link to post Share on other sites More sharing options...
Acieed 1st Gear October 17, 2011 Share October 17, 2011 Not "too many" but anything above $300 per adult traveller. Less than 24 hours, up to $50. http://www.ica.gov.sg/page.aspx?pageid=98 Technically, anything that you bring across the borders are taxable. Not different from most countries, even democratic countries. Try India, even courier a hard disk with data, it's "taxable". Heard even if you buy too many clothing or shoes back from your holidays, the sg custom can also "tax" the items you have bought?! Link to post Share on other sites More sharing options...
Tarzan666 2nd Gear October 17, 2011 Share October 17, 2011 usu ICA close eye la.. u come back from JB on weekend, sometimes u c the car in front of u, whole boot is full of shopping bags, by rite can tax 1.. if u away from SG for less than 24hours..ur entitlement is only stuff bought worth up to S$50. There are brochures all around airport, guess nobody bother to read. Link to post Share on other sites More sharing options...
Mockngbrd Supersonic October 17, 2011 Share October 17, 2011 unlucky ... Link to post Share on other sites More sharing options...
Ocean6576 4th Gear October 17, 2011 Share October 17, 2011 Wonder in the future if we need to bring along receipts as proof of purchase. Imagine to touch down dress in Armanni suit, prada shoes, LV bags. Tumi luggauge, with a Rolex watch and other electronic gadgets where all bought in Singapore previously but customs deem that you had bought when oversea and wanna tax you. On the other hand, if we bought many duty free perfumes, make up/skincare products, are those taxable as well? Link to post Share on other sites More sharing options...
Acieed 1st Gear October 17, 2011 Share October 17, 2011 There are also guidelines for duty free goods. Apparently, all countries have the problem of restricting those who are bypassing regular customs for commercial gains. If putting yourself in the shoes of ICA, how would you manage the situation ? Wonder in the future if we need to bring along receipts as proof of purchase. Imagine to touch down dress in Armanni suit, prada shoes, LV bags. Tumi luggauge, with a Rolex watch and other electronic gadgets where all bought in Singapore previously but customs deem that you had bought when oversea and wanna tax you. On the other hand, if we bought many duty free perfumes, make up/skincare products, are those taxable as well? Link to post Share on other sites More sharing options...
Pokemon Neutral Newbie October 17, 2011 Share October 17, 2011 Who knows if you bring extra and sell on the Net? Why tax items bought abroad for personal use? Letter from Charlton Wee 17 Oct 2011 Today I recently returned to Singapore from a trip to Hong Kong and was stopped to have my baggage checked for any undeclared goods. My luggage was packed with herbs for my family, and I was questioned about contents that I did not know the worth of, as they were given to me by my relative in Hong Kong. I had to give an estimate based on my experience of purchasing herbs in Singapore, as I was told I could be taxed. I found out that all Singaporeans are allowed only up to S$300 worth of non-taxable goods, a rule that no one knew when I asked around later. I can understand it if we are taxed on goods for commercial use or business purposes, but why are we taxed on goods bought overseas that are solely for personal consumption? ↡ Advertisement Link to post Share on other sites More sharing options...
Recommended Posts
Create an account or sign in to comment
You need to be a member in order to leave a comment
Create an account
Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!
Register a new accountSign in
Already have an account? Sign in here.
Sign In NowRelated Discussions
Related Discussions
Eye surgery - cannot drive
Eye surgery - cannot drive
Petrol cheat or just super blur
Petrol cheat or just super blur
Sales pitch for animals
Sales pitch for animals
Cannot anyhow stick SPF decal liao!
Cannot anyhow stick SPF decal liao!
Free healthcare and higher taxes or die and cannot fall sick
Free healthcare and higher taxes or die and cannot fall sick
Toyota Sienta cannot use 16" rims?
Toyota Sienta cannot use 16" rims?
Why cannot transfer car in the first 3mths of ownership
Why cannot transfer car in the first 3mths of ownership
Public Alcohol consumption bill-Cannot have a beer at a BBQ!
Public Alcohol consumption bill-Cannot have a beer at a BBQ!