Jump to content

Think big and bold to boost bus services

Think big and bold to boost bus services

Sign in to follow this  




The Government has been stepping up efforts to improve bus service standards.

It started with the announcement in 2012 of a $1.1 billion Bus Service Enhancement Programme, under which the state finances the purchase and operation of 550 additional public buses. By the end of this year, all of the new buses will be on the road.


That was followed recently by a carrot-and-stick scheme to incentivise operators to keep "excess waiting time" to a minimum. The plan, the first of its kind here, will start with a two-year trial involving 22 services.


And next year, a sophisticated satellite-tracked system that will forecast to the minute when a particular bus will arrive at any given stop.


These are good moves, to be sure. But are they enough? More to the point, do they make a difference where it matters most: to commuters' bus journeys?


Consider for example that the carrot-and-stick scheme - called the Bus Service Reliability Framework - will involve only 8 per cent of services here. And it is only a trial.


Secondly, a satellite-tracked bus arrival forecasting system may be a technological marvel, but nothing beats having buses stick to a dependable bus timetable - whether the timetable is printed on plain paper or is available as a sophisticated app.


Mr Bruno Wildermuth, a respected industry consultant, says a published bus timetable is a must. That way, commuters can plan their day effectively. And regulators can gauge the service of operators.


Mr Wildermuth points out that bus timetables are common in many developed countries, including Japan, Australia, Scandinavia, Germany and Switzerland.


"Not everyone has a computer or a smartphone," Mr Wildermuth says, referring to bus arrival information systems that smartphone users can tap on.


"Secondly, how do I plan for a meeting in town? How do I plan my transfers if there isn't a timetable?"


He says that in Zurich a commuter can plan his journey down to the minute because buses there are required to run to a strict timetable.


In Tokyo, buses are so reliable that commuters can set their watches to a service.


National University of Singapore transport economist Anthony Chin agrees that a fixed timetable is preferred.


"What you need is certainty in arrival times according to a published schedule," he says.


The Land Transport Authority, however, seems to think that timetables are needed only for services that are less frequent.


An LTA spokesman says that when the new arrival system is ready next year, it will be able to provide updates on bus arrival information "so that commuters have more predictability on the arrival of their bus service".


The LTA will then consider the merit of providing timetables "for low-frequency bus services".


This is puzzling. Why not a timetable for all services? After all, the planners have access to a wealth of commuting information through the ez-link card. With some planning, it would be possible to come up with a bus timetable that will benefit the commuter and is feasible for the operator.


So while a satellite-tracked arrival system sounds sophisticated, it is of limited use to commuters who cannot plan journeys in advance.


In fact, LTA and bus planners should go beyond buying buses and tracking journey times. For a move that would have a more significant impact on the daily bus commute, they should revisit the plan to redraw Singapore's bus routes. Mr Raymond Lim made the LTA the central bus route planner when he was transport minister.


The idea was for it to come up with a hub-and-spoke network that is optimal, efficient and not necessarily profit-motivated.


But the changes have been slow in coming. And many bus routes that are extraordinarily long remain. Take Service 196 for instance. It plies between Bedok in the east and Clementi in the west. But most commuters on it actually travel between the city and the two towns. Why not split it into two shorter routes?


Dr Park Byung Joon, head of the Master of Science programme in urban transport management at UniSIM's School of Business, observes that long bus routes are not desirable.


"It has been empirically proven that the longer the bus route, the poorer the bus reliability," he notes. "The Seoul bus reform implemented in 2003 divided Seoul into eight zones and most of the bus routes ran only within a zone.


"Since bus routes became relatively short, the reliability naturally improved."


The Seoul bus reform has been hailed as a success story by transport experts, where decisive government intervention turned around a messy industry.


Then there is the question of whether Singapore's fleet of 4,000-plus public buses is well utilised.


Mr Wildermuth observes large numbers of buses at interchanges - even during peak hours. "Drivers should take tea breaks, not buses," he asserts. He believes, with better manpower planning, operators could do a lot more with their fleets.


Dr Park agrees. "It is well established that simply adding more buses to the fleet is not an effective way of improving bus reliability," he says. "It must come with other measures."


Truth be told, the bus commuter's lot has generally improved. This is especially so for those who use services such as 72, 106 and 922, which got more buses under the Bus Service Enhancement Programme. Many also benefit from new City Direct express services.


But some services are below par. Service 147 has waiting times of as long as 30 minutes; Service 7's departure times from Clementi interchange are patchy; and the infamous 190 made headlines last October when a commuter complained that she could not get on it for 13 times.


To fix the industry conclusively, perhaps bigger, bolder steps need to be taken.


-- ST ILLUSTRATION : Manny Francisco


by Christopher Tan

Sign in to follow this  


Recommended Comments

The 2 biggest problems of buses in SG:


1. Long (and unpredictable) waiting time

2. Too crowded until cannot get on bus.


I think number 1 still not too bad and difficult to control, for example traffic conditions etc. But something can definitely be done for overcrowded buses. Proper planning must be made and adjusted for seasonality for example more services during Xmas and CNY period

Share this comment

Link to comment

Believe it or not, many bus routes are loss making.


It is precisely those buses that are "Too crowded until cannot get on bus." that brings in the dough.


Bus companies can and will ramp by the bus supply, increase the number of routes, but only if govt approves bus fares increase.


With the government in timid lion mode, I doubt they dare to implement this.

Share this comment

Link to comment

Why so hard to implement time table for all buses? If that's the case, it's like taking a flight. If i know my bus is going to come at 8.45, i will be there 5-10 mins earlier to catch the bus.


The app is more like after i have reach the bus-stop, how much more time do i have to wait for my bus to come.


And buses in Singapore is really jam-packed.

Up till now i still don't see any improvement. If they keep developing new towns and heavily dense the population with FT, i think govt should revise the who bus route to cater to this new demand. Up till now i still see my bus stop with the same no. going on the same route. The only difference is some can board the bus, some can't.

Share this comment

Link to comment

Believe it or not, many bus routes are loss making.


It is precisely those buses that are "Too crowded until cannot get on bus." that brings in the dough.


Bus companies can and will ramp by the bus supply, increase the number of routes, but only if govt approves bus fares increase.


With the government in timid lion mode, I doubt they dare to implement this.

Too crowded (or full to the brim) will maximise your revenue no doubt, but passengers that could have gotten in but could not board will translate into a revenue loss isn't it? Maybe they fed up just take cab, or walk home? Operating public transport cannot be like operating airlines, wait for every flight to be full.


Cut down the frequency of those non-profitable bus routes, but make sure the bus timing fixed, for example every 1 hour come once. Commuters can then plan accordingly. Then for those jam packed routes, deploy the buses from the non-profitable routes to increase frequency. Or maybe redesign the buses to make more standing room. Seats take up too much space. Maybe like 70% standing, 30% sitting, shd be enough for those elderly, or disabled.

Share this comment

Link to comment

Create an account or sign in to comment

You need to be a member in order to leave a comment

Create an account

Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!

Register a new account

Sign in

Already have an account? Sign in here.

Sign In Now
  • Featured Stories

    Owner unwilling to pay after workshop rendered service

    A post about a customer who refused to pay after a battery replacement workshop rendered its services has gone viral online. Spotted on its own facebook page, FastFix Car Battery Replacement Service explained how the whole issue came about.  It wrote in its post that its client, Mr C, reached out to them saying that he needed help as his car could not start. After listening to the symptoms the car showed( car still cranks and aircon is not as strong as before), the workshop concluded that it needed a new battery. However, upon reaching Mr C, whose car was parked in the CBD and hence the need to pay for ERP charges, the guys from FastFix realised that it wasn't the battery that needed replacing.

    Concluding that there was nothing the guys from FastFix could do to help, Mr C was then asked to pay for the labour fee that had been pointed out before in their Whatsapp conversation. Unfortunately, Mr C disagreed and refused to pay the $50 that they had agreed on as nothing has been done to his Kia.  There was not much FastFix could do which probably prompted them to 'share their story' of the client on their facebook page.     Here are some of the notable comment in the post.



    MCF Hangout with Follow Me Japan

    Over 60 MyCarForum (MCF) members, together with their partners and families, gathered at Singapore Recreation Club on Saturday afternoon to attend the MCF Hangout with Follow Me Japan. The event, a unique collaboration between sgCarMart and FMJ, offered MCF members insights into the many interesting sights and attractions in Ishikawa, Japan.
      During the event, sgCarMart Senior Automotive Journalist Desmond Chan spoke about some of his personal experiences driving overseas, as well as some key tips on how to best plan and enjoy a road trip. He also briefly touched on some of the unique road conditions and peculiarities when it comes to driving in Japan.
      Additionally, Mr. Yuta Abe from FMJ also presented on the many unique attractions that Ishikawa offers. Ishikawa Prefecture, located 500km away from Tokyo, is bordered on three sides by the Sea of Japan, and by Mt. Hakusan on the fourth. This allows visitors to enjoy the best of both mountainous and sea-facing scenery. Ishikawa is especially beautiful in the Autumn, with bountiful harvests making for delectable cuisine, and spectacular scenery thanks to beautiful natural sights.
      Ms. Mandy Tay, an award-winning photographer, also shared with MCF members her experience travelling in Ishikawa. She shared some of her culinary highlights, such as incredibly fresh oysters, as well as the ample hospitality and kindness of the people of Japan.

    FMJ Managing Director Ms. Risa Nishimura talks about how her experience in planning exciting journeys to Ishikawa Prefecture.  
    sgCarMart Senior Automotive Journalist Desmond Chan speaks about his experiences with drive trips.
    Ms. Mandy Tay talks about her experience travelling in Ishikawa, and shared some of the photos taken there.  
    Head over to her Instagram account to check out more of Mandy Tay's work.  
    A specially curated guide to car rental journeys in Ishikawa has extensive information on unique attraction, beautiful scenery and ideal driving routes.    
    Guests had the chance to sample snacks from Ishikawa.  
    Lucky draw prizes include a selection of unique Japanese snacks, as well as car rental vouchers.  
    To see more photos from the event, click here.