Jump to content

Grab, Uber not exempt from child-seat rules: LTA

Grab, Uber not exempt from child-seat rules: LTA

Sign in to follow this  



blogentry-133713-0-45237900-1486032855_thumb.jpgRide-hailing services such as Grab and Uber are not exempt from rules requiring car seats for young children, the Land Transport Authority (LTA) said yesterday.


Under the Road Traffic Act, it is illegal for cars to carry passengers under 1.35 metres tall without a booster seat or a child restraint.


Taxis are excluded from this ruling as they are considered "public service vehicles", while private-hire car services are not.


Offenders face a fine of $120 and three demerit points.


If charged in court, they can be fined up to $1,000 or jailed up to three months.


LTA said taxis are exempt as it would be "quite unreasonable" for taxi drivers to have to turn away street-hail fares with children under 1.35 metres tall and babies.


"We are not exempting private-hire cars because they are pre-booked and passengers can indicate if they require booster seats or child restraints when making the booking," said a spokesman.


In a fatal accident last June, two young boys, who were not in child seats, were injured after their family's car crashed into a tree in Lentor Avenue.


Mr Sitoh Yih Pin, Chairman for the Government Parliamentary Committee on Transport, said that child-seat regulations for private-hire cars should be "considered and reviewed".


"The key issue here is whether (private-hire cars) should also be deemed as public service vehicles and therefore be exempt from having child seats for children under 1.35m tall," he added.


Nanyang Technological University transport consultant Gopinath Menon said there are "practical difficulties" in making child seats mandatory.


Child seats cannot be permanently installed in taxis and private-hire cars because they ferry different passengers on each trip, he said. The driver would have to keep the seat in the car boot and set it up whenever a child is among the passengers.


But National University of Singapore transport researcher Lee Der Horng said laws requiring car seats should be "universally applicable".


"There is no strong reason why taxis should be exempted from the rule. It's about safety," he said.


As more commuters use booking apps to hire taxis, operators could add an option to request car seats, he said.


Since last August, Grab has offered the option of booking GrabFamily, a six-seater car with a booster seat installed for children between the ages of four and seven.


In a blog post yesterday, Grab said it was monitoring GrabFamily and "did not rule out" introducing baby seats in the future.


In overseas markets, Uber offers UberFamily, a service that allows passengers to request a child seat. It is not currently available here.


The following article is written by Zhaki Abdullah, a Correspondent with The Straits Times.

Sign in to follow this  


Recommended Comments

Why are "public service vehicles and therefore be exempt from having child seats for children under 1.35m tall"? - Public service vehicles will not get into accident, or their passengers will miraculously not get injured just bec they are in public service vehicles (aka Taxi)?? What stoopid logic is this? The authorities who wrote this piece of crap rule to exempt the taxis, shld hv their head examined or made to take taxi without seat belts on.. see if they will die if the taxi kena head on accident.. really PHD...

Share this comment

Link to comment

LTA - Exactly what are you doing? Are you sure you know what you are doing at all?


The road is the same but you have different rules and regulations imposed on different types of drivers.


Do you mean one group of drivers are safer than the other and hence, some rules apply and some rules don't apply.

Share this comment

Link to comment

Create an account or sign in to comment

You need to be a member in order to leave a comment

Create an account

Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!

Register a new account

Sign in

Already have an account? Sign in here.

Sign In Now
  • Featured Stories

    Owner unwilling to pay after workshop rendered service

    A post about a customer who refused to pay after a battery replacement workshop rendered its services has gone viral online. Spotted on its own facebook page, FastFix Car Battery Replacement Service explained how the whole issue came about.  It wrote in its post that its client, Mr C, reached out to them saying that he needed help as his car could not start. After listening to the symptoms the car showed( car still cranks and aircon is not as strong as before), the workshop concluded that it needed a new battery. However, upon reaching Mr C, whose car was parked in the CBD and hence the need to pay for ERP charges, the guys from FastFix realised that it wasn't the battery that needed replacing.

    Concluding that there was nothing the guys from FastFix could do to help, Mr C was then asked to pay for the labour fee that had been pointed out before in their Whatsapp conversation. Unfortunately, Mr C disagreed and refused to pay the $50 that they had agreed on as nothing has been done to his Kia.  There was not much FastFix could do which probably prompted them to 'share their story' of the client on their facebook page.     Here are some of the notable comment in the post.



    MCF Hangout with Follow Me Japan

    Over 60 MyCarForum (MCF) members, together with their partners and families, gathered at Singapore Recreation Club on Saturday afternoon to attend the MCF Hangout with Follow Me Japan. The event, a unique collaboration between sgCarMart and FMJ, offered MCF members insights into the many interesting sights and attractions in Ishikawa, Japan.
      During the event, sgCarMart Senior Automotive Journalist Desmond Chan spoke about some of his personal experiences driving overseas, as well as some key tips on how to best plan and enjoy a road trip. He also briefly touched on some of the unique road conditions and peculiarities when it comes to driving in Japan.
      Additionally, Mr. Yuta Abe from FMJ also presented on the many unique attractions that Ishikawa offers. Ishikawa Prefecture, located 500km away from Tokyo, is bordered on three sides by the Sea of Japan, and by Mt. Hakusan on the fourth. This allows visitors to enjoy the best of both mountainous and sea-facing scenery. Ishikawa is especially beautiful in the Autumn, with bountiful harvests making for delectable cuisine, and spectacular scenery thanks to beautiful natural sights.
      Ms. Mandy Tay, an award-winning photographer, also shared with MCF members her experience travelling in Ishikawa. She shared some of her culinary highlights, such as incredibly fresh oysters, as well as the ample hospitality and kindness of the people of Japan.

    FMJ Managing Director Ms. Risa Nishimura talks about how her experience in planning exciting journeys to Ishikawa Prefecture.  
    sgCarMart Senior Automotive Journalist Desmond Chan speaks about his experiences with drive trips.
    Ms. Mandy Tay talks about her experience travelling in Ishikawa, and shared some of the photos taken there.  
    Head over to her Instagram account to check out more of Mandy Tay's work.  
    A specially curated guide to car rental journeys in Ishikawa has extensive information on unique attraction, beautiful scenery and ideal driving routes.    
    Guests had the chance to sample snacks from Ishikawa.  
    Lucky draw prizes include a selection of unique Japanese snacks, as well as car rental vouchers.  
    To see more photos from the event, click here.