BabyBlade Internal Moderator July 22, 2021 Share July 22, 2021 Something that bugs me a lot. To swerve or not to swerve to avoid hitting an animal if it suddenly darts out onto the road infront of you. In Singapore's context, usually a dog, cat, sambar deer, monkeys? What else? Our natural instinct would be to swerve right? I'm an animal lover and instinctively, I would as well. But is that really the right thing to do? There's so many factors to consider, road condition, any cars near me, will the car behind me be able to stop safely? But fact is we don't have the luxury of time to analyze. What are the consequence of swerving to avoid hitting an animal? You place your passengers at risk, most will react by swerving left or right, you may end up hitting a barrier, a tree, you may take a car or two along with you, or even a motorcycle with a pillion, you may end up causing a chain collision. Worst still, you may end up mounting the curb and taking a bystander on the pavement along with you (if it's on small roads). What if you suddenly e-brake? You may cause a horrific rear collision if the car behind you is unable to react in time. What happens then if you hit the animal head on? You end up feeling guilty for killing an animal, you'll end up paying for your broken bumper/fender or other repairs. But hopefully the impact ends there. Importantly what we should do is to maintain a proper following distance, be attentive on the road and react properly on the road. Unless, you are dead sure of the road and traffic condition around you (no cars, no bikes, no pedestrians), don't swerve. Not saying that animals lives ain't important but just saying don't jeopardize the lives of others while trying to save that dog, cat or squirrel. And dog owners, please keep your pets leashed. No use crying if you don't leash your pets and then it ends up a road kill. The only fault of the driver then would be if he hits and then run. ↡ Advertisement 4 2 Link to post Share on other sites More sharing options...
inlinesix Supersonic July 22, 2021 Share July 22, 2021 Around Lorong Halus got a lot of stray dog. Brake hard. Don't swerve. 8 Link to post Share on other sites More sharing options...
DOBIEMKZ Turbocharged July 22, 2021 Share July 22, 2021 (edited) 12 minutes ago, BabyBlade said: Something that bugs me a lot. To swerve or not to swerve to avoid hitting an animal if it suddenly darts out onto the road infront of you. In Singapore's context, usually a dog, cat, sambar deer, monkeys? What else? Our natural instinct would be to swerve right? I'm an animal lover and instinctively, I would as well. But is that really the right thing to do? There's so many factors to consider, road condition, any cars near me, will the car behind me be able to stop safely? But fact is we don't have the luxury of time to analyze. What are the consequence of swerving to avoid hitting an animal? You place your passengers at risk, most will react by swerving left or right, you may end up hitting a barrier, a tree, you may take a car or two along with you, or even a motorcycle with a pillion, you may end up causing a chain collision. Worst still, you may end up mounting the curb and taking a bystander on the pavement along with you (if it's on small roads). What if you suddenly e-brake? You may cause a horrific rear collision if the car behind you is unable to react in time. What happens then if you hit the animal head on? You end up feeling guilty for killing an animal, you'll end up paying for your broken bumper/fender or other repairs. But hopefully the impact ends there. Importantly what we should do is to maintain a proper following distance, be attentive on the road and react properly on the road. Unless, you are dead sure of the road and traffic condition around you (no cars, no bikes, no pedestrians), don't swerve. Not saying that animals lives ain't important but just saying don't jeopardize the lives of others while trying to save that dog, cat or squirrel. And dog owners, please keep your pets leashed. No use crying if you don't leash your pets and then it ends up a road kill. The only fault of the driver then would be if he hits and then run. Personally, I think it is only safe to swerve if there is adequate allowance/buffer and without endangering others . Otherwise just stomp hard on the brake and hope for the best or to minimise or mitigate collision impact. Anyway that rear car should also keep an adequate distance from the front vehicle. Edited July 22, 2021 by DOBIEMKZ 2 Link to post Share on other sites More sharing options...
Thaiyotakamli Supersonic July 22, 2021 Share July 22, 2021 Brake hard is the best. Swerve will swipe motorcyclist 5 1 Link to post Share on other sites More sharing options...
BabyBlade Internal Moderator July 22, 2021 Author Share July 22, 2021 35 minutes ago, inlinesix said: Around Lorong Halus got a lot of stray dog. Brake hard. Don't swerve. If you're at Lorong Halus an area with a lot of stay dogs, then one should be approaching the area slow. Braking hard may cause serious accidents from happening too especially if there is a motorcycle following behind. Best is not to e-brake or swerve, unless you're certain it's safe to do so. 3 Link to post Share on other sites More sharing options...
BabyBlade Internal Moderator July 22, 2021 Author Share July 22, 2021 What the Volvo did in the video was to brake hard, rear car was either following too close or wasn't paying attention. Could have taken the motorcyclist too. Such a scenario where traffic is heavy I really don't recommend braking hard. Saved the dog's life though, but could have been worse for many others. 2 1 Link to post Share on other sites More sharing options...
Nolicense Turbocharged July 22, 2021 Share July 22, 2021 5 minutes ago, BabyBlade said: If you're at Lorong Halus an area with a lot of stay dogs, then one should be approaching the area slow. Braking hard may cause serious accidents from happening too especially if there is a motorcycle following behind. Best is not to e-brake or swerve, unless you're certain it's safe to do so. quite right. if you know the traffic is busy and you dont know what you will hit when you drive erratically by swerving, you pay for the damages and life if someone suffers. we get our license to operate a 2 to 3 ton machine not to harm other road users. it is basic common sense not to drive erratically when other road users expect our behaviour to be predictable 1 Link to post Share on other sites More sharing options...
inlinesix Supersonic July 22, 2021 Share July 22, 2021 5 minutes ago, BabyBlade said: If you're at Lorong Halus an area with a lot of stay dogs, then one should be approaching the area slow. Braking hard may cause serious accidents from happening too especially if there is a motorcycle following behind. Best is not to e-brake or swerve, unless you're certain it's safe to do so. This stretch of road is going towards TPE or KPE. Speed limit is 70km/h (I think). Cannot go too slow la. 1 Link to post Share on other sites More sharing options...
Nolicense Turbocharged July 22, 2021 Share July 22, 2021 6 minutes ago, BabyBlade said: What the Volvo did in the video was to brake hard, rear car was either following too close or wasn't paying attention. Could have taken the motorcyclist too. Such a scenario where traffic is heavy I really don't recommend braking hard. Saved the dog's life though, but could have been worse for many others. in this case the volvo hit from behind. he will claim the tivoli max. speed not very fast but maybe blame following distance too close. tivoli suay max 2 Link to post Share on other sites More sharing options...
mersaylee Supersonic July 22, 2021 Share July 22, 2021 When you hit something...swerve or no swerve is also suay 😁 1 Link to post Share on other sites More sharing options...
Ho2786 4th Gear July 22, 2021 Share July 22, 2021 brake and hope for the best if still kenna just tell yourself you did the best 1 Link to post Share on other sites More sharing options...
Beregond Supersonic July 22, 2021 Share July 22, 2021 Although i say its wrong to swerve. i ownself also did that when similar incident happen to me. natural instinct just kick in. i ebrake and swerve. lucky for me. i didnt buang any 1.... 5 Link to post Share on other sites More sharing options...
BabyBlade Internal Moderator July 22, 2021 Author Share July 22, 2021 3 minutes ago, Beregond said: Although i say its wrong to swerve. i ownself also did that when similar incident happen to me. natural instinct just kick in. i ebrake and swerve. lucky for me. i didnt buang any 1.... 8 years ago, I swerved to avoid hitting a dog that ran onto the road. Skidded a short distance with my bike. Unfortunately I also hit the dog but it ran away. Luckily for me though, a Comfort taxi managed to e-brake and didn't run over me. 4 Link to post Share on other sites More sharing options...
Jamesc Hypersonic July 22, 2021 Share July 22, 2021 I like dogs more than humans. Save the dog and knock the human. 4 Link to post Share on other sites More sharing options...
Shibadog Turbocharged July 22, 2021 Share July 22, 2021 for me, i would consider the size of the animal. if animal is elephant, buffalo, cow etc, i will brake n swerve if road conditions permit. Maybe the same for a big pig/tapir. This mainly for my road trips in msia/thai. but then i also hv a habit of being mindful of the traffic behind/beside me as i drive. for smaller animals, it's usually safer to drive though without swerving. That's the recommendation by road authorities too, IIRC. so far i've hit birds n snakes, nothing bigger. Encountered a buffalo in south thai which i didn't argue with regarding right-of-way. if u drive in south NZ, there's lots of roadkill. Birds, possums etc. If the driver swerved, he might end up going over a cliff. 2 Link to post Share on other sites More sharing options...
Nolicense Turbocharged July 22, 2021 Share July 22, 2021 6 hours ago, BabyBlade said: 8 years ago, I swerved to avoid hitting a dog that ran onto the road. Skidded a short distance with my bike. Unfortunately I also hit the dog but it ran away. Luckily for me though, a Comfort taxi managed to e-brake and didn't run over me. bb would become a real angel then.. lol 1 Link to post Share on other sites More sharing options...
Nolicense Turbocharged July 22, 2021 Share July 22, 2021 1 minute ago, Shibadog said: for me, i would consider the size of the animal. if animal is elephant, buffalo, cow etc, i will brake n swerve if road conditions permit. Maybe the same for a big pig/tapir. This mainly for my road trips in msia/thai. but then i also hv a habit of being mindful of the traffic behind/beside me as i drive. for smaller animals, it's usually safer to drive though without swerving. That's the recommendation by road authorities too, IIRC. so far i've hit birds n snakes, nothing bigger. Encountered a buffalo in south thai which i didn't argue with regarding right-of-way. if u drive in south NZ, there's lots of roadkill. Birds, possums etc. If the driver swerved, he might end up going over a cliff. you are right.. think of survival. who would not swerve if it is a tree, elephant or a cliff? Link to post Share on other sites More sharing options...
Atonchia Supersonic July 22, 2021 Share July 22, 2021 7 hours ago, BabyBlade said: What the Volvo did in the video was to brake hard, rear car was either following too close or wasn't paying attention. Could have taken the motorcyclist too. Such a scenario where traffic is heavy I really don't recommend braking hard. Saved the dog's life though, but could have been worse for many others. This case was OK.... No life lost and bumper can be repaired. It's really hard to provide a hard and fast rule. Keep situational awareness high while driving....... With good SA, then if sudden event happens, just decide if lost of a dog life is better than the lost of a motorcyclist.... Your question is same as "Will you save your mum or you wife." type of question.... 😅 ↡ Advertisement Link to post Share on other sites More sharing options...
Recommended Posts
Create an account or sign in to comment
You need to be a member in order to leave a comment
Create an account
Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!
Register a new accountSign in
Already have an account? Sign in here.
Sign In NowRelated Discussions
Related Discussions
Mother of all PMD PMA PAB thread
Mother of all PMD PMA PAB thread
Food delivery firms take up third-party liability insurance
Food delivery firms take up third-party liability insurance
Man finds wrecked car with engine running & driver missing at Seletar road junction
Man finds wrecked car with engine running & driver missing at Seletar road junction
Fatal Accidents - Driver or Road Problem?
Fatal Accidents - Driver or Road Problem?
Freak Car Accident. Victim in ICU
Freak Car Accident. Victim in ICU
ACS boy dies during high adventure course
ACS boy dies during high adventure course
Car aircon check / servicing from $9.90! Edwin Garage - 100% cheapest in Town. For Conti, Japanese and Korean cars.
Car aircon check / servicing from $9.90! Edwin Garage - 100% cheapest in Town. For Conti, Japanese and Korean cars.
Advice for accident
Advice for accident