Jump to content

For change to work, LTA must understand bus operations better than operators do

For change to work, LTA must understand bus operations better than operators do

ST_Opinion

13,308 views

blog-0227968001402239918.jpg

blogentry-133904-0-32117400-1402239713_thumb.jpg

The recent announcement that Singapore's public bus transport was going to be overhauled brought my mind back to the last time such a major change was attempted.

 

It was 1984 and I was in the then Ministry of Communications, in a room outside the office of the Permanent Secretary.

With me, waiting to see the boss, was the man who was about to change the face of public transport here.

He had responded to the call to inject competition into the bus service - then monopolised by Singapore Bus Service (SBS).

When I asked him how he felt about the undertaking, he stuck out his tongue and smiled.

Before he could elaborate, the door opened and we were both ushered into the meeting.

 

To this day, I am not sure what to make of his response.

Was he wary of taking on the mighty SBS, or relishing the new challenge?

Whatever it was, Trans-Island Bus Services (Tibs) soon started operation, and thus began Singapore's experiment with two bus operators.

It was a period in Singapore's history when competition became the new mantra to bring about better and more responsive service.

In telecoms, StarHub and M1 were started to take on SingTel.

 

Even Singapore Press Holdings caught the competition bug, starting a short-lived TV business to take on MediaCorp.

But it was all done Singapore-style - carefully managed with none of the free-for-all that characterised markets elsewhere.

Perhaps no other service exemplified this better than public bus transport, with the market now split between two big players, SBS and SMRT (which bought Tibs).

 

So, what went wrong with this two-operator model?

You are likely to get different answers depending on who you ask.

Speak to the operators and they will complain about their inability to raise fares to cover their revenues, especially their bus operations.

This, they argue, affected service levels because insufficient revenue means less investments in buses and drivers to keep up with rising demand and expectations.

 

For commuters though, the story couldn't be more different.

They see two profitable publicly listed companies more intent on pleasing their shareholders than commuters.

In the case of SMRT under its previous management, they saw a company more focused on its retail property business than its public transport obligations.

 

So, is the recently announced overhaul of the system, with the Government owning the assets and outsourcing operations to outside parties, the solution?

Perhaps it is, though it isn't the right question to ask because there isn't one right solution for public transport.

Around the world you will see many different arrangements working, with varying degrees of success.

 

A nationalised system can work as well as one operated through the free market, or one based on a contracting system with many players.

What's more important is to be clear what conditions are necessary for any one arrangement to work, and then to make sure those conditions prevail.

 

So, what will make a contracting system work?

I can cite at least three factors.

First, it is critical that the Land Transport Authority (LTA) be a strong regulator and planner with the expertise and professionalism to do its job.

It requires the LTA to have a deep understanding of the travelling pattern of commuters to a greater degree than currently, so that it can work out how to meet the demand as efficiently and effectively as possible.

This is a big and complicated job, and to do it well, the LTA will have to understand bus operations even better than the operators do.

Regulators are usually at a disadvantage compared with those running the business because a great deal of the knowledge comes from operating the system and solving problems along the way.

 

But for the contracting model to work, the LTA will have to do better.

It will have its work cut out for it.

The second important condition is to ensure the well-being and professionalism of workers in the bus companies, especially bus drivers.

What we must guard against is a repeat of what happened to the cleaning industry when companies started to outsource the work.

The result was that the wages of cleaners suffered because, in trying to win the contracts, cleaning companies bid ever lower prices.

And if they failed to extend the contract at the next tender, these workers were laid off, or ended up working for a different winning bidder sometimes at even lower wages.

 

No one bothered to improve the skill of cleaners; they were interested only in lowering costs.

Things are much better now with the introduction of the progressive wage model, but the experience showed how workers on the lowest rung of the ladder end up with the worst deal.

How to ensure the same thing does not happen to bus drivers?

This is a critical issue because, no matter how new the buses, or how well-planned the routes, a pleasant and reliable bus service depends on committed and well-trained drivers.

Their interest and well-being need to be taken care of in the new model.

Finally, the success of this change depends on Singaporeans agreeing how much bus services need to be subsidised.

It is a sign of how the thinking has changed, that the question being posed is not whether it should be but by how much.

Indeed, the Government is already subsiding bus operations substantially with the $1.1 billion bus plan.

But it couldn't continue pumping money indefinitely in the present set-up, not when the two operators are publicly-listed companies which channel a large part of their earnings to their own shareholders.

In the new model, government subsidies will raise fewer objections because the state now owns all the assets.

 

But the issue still remains: How much subsidy?

This question cannot be left unanswered and determined from year to year depending on how much shortfall there is.

At some point, the Government has to decide what the level should be, and peg fares accordingly.

It would be another sticking-the-tongue-out moment.

 

-- ST ILLUSTRATION : MIEL

 

by Han Fook Kwang, Editor at Large




0 Comments


Recommended Comments

There are no comments to display.

Create an account or sign in to comment

You need to be a member in order to leave a comment

Create an account

Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!

Register a new account

Sign in

Already have an account? Sign in here.

Sign In Now
  • Godzilla Minus One: Surprisingly emotional and poignant

    When one thinks of Godzilla movies, one imagines an oversized amphibious dinosaur generating a terrifying heat ray from its mouth and fighting with other oversized monsters. Meh, nothing special, right? Wrong. Here’s why Godzilla Minus One should be an action movie you should definitely catch. In this version, the timeless clash between monster and man is once again set against the tumultuous backdrop of post-war Japan. But, unlike typical action films that dive headfirst into destruction a

    chrissyc

    chrissyc

    In a hyper-connected world, your physical presence is more important than ever

    The advent of apps and the Internet have revolutionised our ability to connect instantaneously. From social media to video calls to messaging apps, our capacity for real-time communication is unprecedented. However, it seems that the more hyperconnected we are online, the further apart we're growing in real life. Experts' Consensus Doctors, scientists, and specialists have all reached the same conclusion: Staring at our devices causes us to drift further apart – a trend I've obser

    jeresinex

    jeresinex

    I have a new favourite game - Dave the Diver!

    Nowadays I think many people have a Nintendo Switch, considering how it is often given away as a free gift when you sign up for credit cards,etc. Instead of just playing Mario Kart, Overcooked and Pokemon, I have another game to introduce to you all! The game is Dave the Diver. This game has completely captivated me with its delightful blend of adventure and relaxation. From the moment I dove into its vibrant underwater world, I was hooked. The gameplay mechanics strike that perfect b

    Cordless vacuum cleaners: A young adult's best friend?

    Every young adult probably arrives at the same point when they’ve started working for a few years: Household chores start to become more enjoyable. Don’t get me wrong – they don’t have to be one’s favourite activity on earth. But chores start to make sense: An environment that’s put-together is always a welcome haven, whether it’s returning home after a long day out, or simply staying in over the weekend (or when you’re working from home.) As a young adult myself, I've come to appreciate an

    donutdontu

    donutdontu

×
×
  • Create New...