Jump to content



Alternative to Speed Cams?

By Blogger on 18 Jul 2010

Attached Image: speedcam.jpg

My favourite theory for the fact that traffic is always so heavy and slow on the PIE between Adam and BKE exit is the speed camera planted in the middle. I believe that the threat of being caught on candid camera and the innate instinct of many Singapore drivers to play it safe is the reason why the average speed along that stretch plummets so drastically compared to the stretches immediately before and after. It is of course made worse by the fact that huge signs advertise the speed camera's existence way way way in advance so some kiasu drivers already start slowing down.

With that, I guess it would hardly come as a surprise if I said that I hate speed cameras and curse at them each time they seemingly cause the traffic congestion I'm stuck in. Yet deep down, I know that speed cameras have a role to play in road safety. Some stretches of roads are way too dangerous to travel at breakneck speeds and it is far better that we all put up with a traffic slowdown compared to people dying or getting injured from accidents. And that pretty much sums my attitude to speed cameras; I hate them but I grudgingly accept that they serve a purpose.

So it piqued my interest, when I recently came across an anecdote in a book that described an interesting and speed camera-less way of ensuring that motorists keep to a safe traveling speed on dangerous stretches of roads. Surprisingly, all it requires is some paint!

The road in question is Lake Shore Drive in Chicago and for years, a famous S-curve along the road claimed the lives of many accident victims. Some even call it the "Dead Man's Curve". In 2006, the city adopted a novel solution that has drastically reduced the number of accidents through the clever use of road paint to create an illusion that caused drivers to subconsciously slow down. Horizontal stripes were painted across the width of the road. These stripes are not strips or bumps that forcefully slowed down the cars. Rather, as the stripes got closer to the curve, the space between each stripe would become smaller and smaller. While driving along, a driver would get the sensation that the car was actually speeding up even if it was traveling at the same speed all along. Instinctively, he would tap on the brakes to slow down!

Personally, this idea really speaks to me. It is elegant, cheap and it only affects drivers at the most dangerous parts. This is a solution that LTA should definitely be looking into!

Attached Image: lake_shore_lines.png

References: Thaler & Sunstein, Nudge, 2008, Yale University Press

motoring, speed cameras, speeding and 1 more...

Viewed: 415 times

Related Blog Posts
Written by Blogger
Not only do their passion for cars burn pavements, their thoughts and ideas on cars are as fast as the word go.

  • 1
Circuit Jul 18 2010 03:18 PM
part true and part not true

the lines already in use at those turning points at expressway exits, and ECP lane,

yes is slowing car down,
at the same time the lines are slippery ! bikes lost grips on those lines , same as cars. SLIPPERY WHEN WET!

those lines at Dairy farm area, already become side arrows liao. they scrape away the lines liao.
think cars and bike slip and loss grip on those lines.

  • 1
Car Makes

Please select a car make

Facebook Likes
   Featured Blog Post
Volkswagen has revealed that its ‘R’ brand performance models will soon become more wild and less...
A rare Lexus LFA has crashed in Singapore last week and with less than 10 units on our shores and...
With only 12bhp in difference between the BMW M5 and the Mercedes-AMG, which of these high-perfor...
When we interviewed the Assistant Large Project Leader of the 2017 Honda Civic Type R, he said th...
A Proton has been caught on someone's dashcam driving recklessly and crashing into a Porsche...
38-year-old Walter Wong was killed when the Tesla Model X he was in crashed into a concrete divid...
   Lifestyle Articles